I have recently been plowing through the House of Night series by P.C. and Kristen Cast. The first thing that strikes me about the series is the feeling of “Oh. Great. Another vampire series. Whoop-dee-doo.” The language and storytelling aren’t bad, though, so I kept reading after the first book thinking that this could get good. And it did. Sort of. Without giving anything away – and really I’m not even going to discuss much plot – I have to say I am sort of disappointed after all.
The story has some intriguing points – it’s set in Oklahoma, which isn’t “vampire story” territory for many authors, and it also creates an alternate reality where becoming a vampire is a whole different process from what is traditional in literature – mainly in that vampires are pretty commonplace in society, through they do sort of self-segregate when they are making the transition from human to vampire. Part of that is going to the nearest House of Night – a move that saves the “fledglings” a painful death from the lack of closeness to a vampire who has fully changed.
What I dislike is that this book is marketed “Young Adult” or “Teen” and the subject matter quickly becomes far too mature for that age group, in my not so humble opinion. My husband and I had a talk about the fact that many authors writing for the teen audience say that the stories get blatantly sexual, or otherwise age-inappropriate because “that’s how teens really are.” Um, well, not really. No. I remember being a teen not so long ago, and I know a few teens and trust me while there have been and always will be “wild” kids who do go out and do indulge in questionable behavior, it’s not as commonplace as one would think. It may, however, become commonplace when the kids who read have role models who go around making bad choices.
Don’t get me wrong, main characters shouldn’t be perfect little angels, but they should show the same amount of common sense and judgement that I would expect to see from a normal teen. Social gaffes? To be expected. Miscommunication and trust issues between friends? Heck yeah. Normal teen behavior. Cheating on your boyfriend, with whom you’ve remained chaste, by having sex with a teacher ( to cite an example)? Um. Red light. Even if the world tilted on its axis and vampires were real this would not be “normal” teen behavior. The proof is in the way the media, schools districts, et al go up in arms over the sex-with-students issue. It’s not a commonplace behavior. It’s not appropriate for teens to read that junk, and I see no reason such a – we’ll say mature for lack of a better term – subject should ever make it into fiction targeted for anyone under 20. (If I had my way it’d be like 40 or something, but maybe that’s ’cause I plan to have kids in the future and I wouldn’t want my daughters – or sons - reading that kind of smut.)
I will grant that it’s portrayed as a bad move, and the character involved in this little affair pays a price, but despite the moral “justice” involved I just don’t think sexual themes should be in fiction aimed at our youth. It’s not just the House of Night series, either. There have been several so-called “teen” books that I’ve picked up and then gotten rid of because, let’s face it, there was more smut in those books than in any of the racier romance novels I’ve come across. And yes, I do read romance novels that have sex in them (mostly ’cause I can’t find them without sex scenes), but people I’m old enough to know what the heck is going on with my own sexuality, and I don’t have a raging batch of hormones and teen drama encouraging me to rebel and otherwise get myself into improbably sticky situations.
I’m not a raging conservative, but I can’t condone have sexual themes – or just outright sex – in books aimed at kids between the ages of 12 -17+. (And believe me, 12 year old kids have probably come across this stuff because it’s not sorted into sections that give age ranges like 12-14, 15-17, 18+ or anything – thought maybe they should be sorted that way.) At this point, I don’t know what the authors are thinking, why the editors are letting this stuff stay in the books, and why publishers are getting away with sending out such a vast quantity of low-quality print.
There are good teen books out there, and some of them are even enjoyable for the older teens. None of them need sex, drug abuse, alcohol, or even the high-school-kid-at-a-frat-party to make them good or enjoyable reads. One thing I can assure you is that, for the safety of my children (assuming I have any) and for the sake of instilling in them some sense of moral compass, I will be reading any book they pick up in the “Young Adult” or “Teen” section before they get the OK to read it.
As for the House of Night series…it’s not a bad set of books – not groundbreaking, but good. I just wouldn’t want it in the hands of anyone under 21. No kidding, folks. I hate to say it, but when it comes to issues of age-appropriateness some books should be either censored, or moved into the Adult section. Even in fiction, one has to consider the real world implications of a character’s choices. We use literature as a vehicle for learning, exploration, and self-discovery. For young minds (especially those that are laden with hormones, social issues, and other concerns) we should not market misbehavior and sexual themes as appropriate reading for either enjoyment or learning.
As a final note: all comments must be approved before they’re posted. Any foul language or anything that qualifies in my opinion as outright stupidity will be banned. I am the autocratic dictator of this blog and will weed out comments, or publish comments as I see fit. So if you’re just here for a fight, go elsewhere. If you’re here for a discussion, we’ll discuss.