Posted By Grand High Poobah on June 26, 2009
At long last, I have finally read The Jane Austen Book Club.
I have to admit, I’m still not completely certain whether I like the book or not, but I can safely say that I do like some of the characters from the book very much. The book tells the story of the six members of the Jane Austen Book Club, which is started by a woman named Jocelyn in order to let friends get together, read Austen, and discuss her works with each other. This is an idea that probably appeals to any Austen fan since only another Austen fan can truly appreciate what it is we are talking about when we mention our favorite books, or this and that character.
Of the six characters, my favorite was Bernadette, who seemed to repeat herself often and not really give a damn. She was perhaps of all the characters the most comfortable in her own skin.
Now, for you Austenites out there, this book may not be as much about Austen as you would like. It is written in such a way that Austen’s works play a role, but that the real story is almost a series of mini-biographies of each character. It explains why or how Austen is relevant to them, perhaps how they came to reading Austen, and in the end how reading Austen or being in the book club made a difference to them. That, I think, may be the point: the power of Austen to bring such difference and diverse people together with something in common. It’s something I noticed in my Jane Austen class this semester.
We all had different ideas about Austen, different backgrounds, different levels of expertise on Austen’s life and works, but we had the common factor of being interested in Austen and willing to say what we thought of her works, or her life. It resulted in more comraderie than most classes I’ve ever been in.
Even the three sole guys in the class got carried away with it, though some still seemed to want to scratch their head and ask why anyone would read or write so many books about marriage.
Each character in this book has their own personality, their own troubles, their own past and conflicts. Yet they have Austen in common and their social connections through the book club in common. They interact with each other and get to know each other - and grow to accept the sole guy in the Club, Grigg.
Is it worth reading? I would say yes. Worth having in your library? Certainly. Worth poring over? Perhaps, but I can’t be sure how much meaning there is supposed to be behind any of it.
My one complaint is that the narration is inconsistent - not in that it changes point of view - and you never know who is telling the story, or whether it’s even someone in particular. It drove me sort of crazy in places. That’s an element that I think needs work because it wasn’t “consistent inconsistency”, it just seemed ill organized to me. I could be wrong, but that’s how it was for me.
I was also surprised by how the story just sort of ends, but then I considered it and I realized that Austen’s books seem to do that, too. You get to the end and you know there’s more to the story. There’s something even after the ‘happily ever after’ that we’ll never read about. So, I was satisfied.
I would recommend the book, but with the caution that it may not be what you expect and it may be a little hard to get into. I did enjoy the read, though. I’d be willing to re-read it after a little time has passed. It could do with more perusal.
VN:F [1.2.3_620]
Rating: 8.5/10 (2 votes cast)
Category: Fiction Review |
2 Comments »
Tags: Allegra, Austenite, Bernadette, book club, Corrine, Daniel, Emma, fiction, Grigg, Jane Austen, Jane Austen Fan Fiction, Jocelyn, Mansfield Park, Mysteries of Udolpho, Northanger Abbey, Persuasion, Pride and Prejudice, Prudie, reading, Sylvia